What is a good, cheap liquid eye liner?

All the liquid liners I've tried have either been flaky and like chipped off or were really shiny and wet looking. I just want a clean black liquid liner that isn't increadably expensive. thanks a lot!What is a good, cheap liquid eye liner?
any nyc liner is cleap and works pretty well


Iwould reccomend saving up though and getting one that works well like almay intense i-color liquid linerWhat is a good, cheap liquid eye liner?
palladio. you can get it at sally's. i'm not sure how cheap you're looking for, but it's like around $7 i think? i can't remember. i got it in dark brown, and i love it. and usually i hate liquid eyeliners.
avon do a really good one that lasts ages!
By far the best is Lineworks Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner by Maybeline





Why You'll Love It


This waterproof liquid liner features a felt tip for easy control and mistake-proof application.





* Long-lasting formula


* No smudges, smears or runs
basically you get what you pay for. the cheap liquid liners arent really that good. If youre willing to spend more defs go to Sephora, MAC, or estee lauder.
I recently got collection 2000 waterproof liquid eye liner. It lasted quite well and didnt really come off til i got tired and rubbed my eyes. Got it for under 拢3
The cheaper you go the worst the results. Tried Wet N Wild?





Do you ever shake up the ingrediants, they can settle and make results half bad, than they should be doing.





Maybelline might be cheaper better quality via drugstore than Wet N Wild brand.
Loreal Lineur Intense Defining Liquid. haha that doesnt even sound like an eyeliner name. but it works well. you can get it a CVS, Walgreens, WalMart, all the places like that.
avon has alot of nice eyeliners, cheap
Collection 2000 have amazing ones, they're cheap and easy 2 apply as well as lasting ages!!
wet and wild is good


tons of colors and you can find it at any drug store

stars myspace