Do you like liquid or pencil eye liner?

Pencil eye liner all the way.


Cuss one time I was at a store, and I saw some eye liner.I was like ';eh.I'll try it';


and bad idea.I didn't really know how to use it all that well I guess.


I did the same thing as I would do with my pencil eye liner, then I let go of my eyes, and ALL OF THE EYE LINER WENT INSIDE MY EYE!


I could see like pure black in my eye!I thought I would have to call the Poison people!I was so freaked out!I thought I was gonna go blind people!


but thankfully it washed out really easily.I threw that thing in the trash so freaking fast.It's a health risk people!





Which do you prefer and why?Do you like liquid or pencil eye liner?
I know what you're talking about. That happened only because liquid eye-liner usually goes on your upper lids, while you can put pencil liner on the inside of your eye. You could put liquid eyeliner on the bottom too, but it would have to be done carefully along your bottom eyelashes.





Also, if you like the look of liquid eyeliner, but hate the mess, you could try Eye Pen. It's kind of like a marker, which you line your eyes with. It's way easier to use.Do you like liquid or pencil eye liner?
liquid for me. I don't know, i guess i have a steady hand or something but i'm good at it, and it comes out looking really pretty and smooth. I just cant use pencil, it never works out for me, its too like crayon-y looking or too thick for my eyes. It stays on for a while too, so i guess if your a good applier for liquid you'll really like it.
I prefer pencil. It's easier to put on, and its less messy.





I tried liquid once. Such a bad idea. It got me mad, cause it was icky. I would mess up so many times! Not even funny. I spilled it on my hands, and I had to go to school like that. Yeah, and I got it in my eye too. Except, it was just like a line of it, but my whole eye turned red. Not fun.
Pencil all the way.





Liquid is hard to get use to and you'll need like a full day of not going anywhere to practice with it.





You can risk getting it in your eye or messing up and its really hard to get off.





I use NYC Color eyeliner..and I love it. Its only .99 hahaha








:O
Yeah, Its pretty hard to get on, it always get in my eye :X


I only use it on my top lid, its much easier, and I don't have to use black eyeshadow. Then for the bottom, I use pencil, a really good kind so it doesn't look stupid.


♥
I like the kind from Bobbi Brown that has a little brush and a tiny bottle of black eyeliner stuff hah. It looks just like the liquid when it's on but it's really easy to get a perfect line.
pencil or retractable eyeliner if i'm in a rush.


and liquid if i'm going to be out all day because it lasts longer. it takes a while to get used to but it leaves a thinner line and looks cleaner.
Pencil, I like the way it looks more and liquid eye liner is SO hard to use. I honestly can't do it without making my eyes look like total crap ahh maybe it's just me lol but my hand is always shaky haha.
I use pencil for the bottom and liquid for the top. Most people do. I like to use pencil on the bottom cause i looks better and liquid looks better on top.
I use liquid eyeliner. I find it goes on easier, although I have never used the pencil type of eyeliner. I should try it, I guess. Next time I go to the store, I'll get some. :)
i like liquid eye liner coz iys make my eyes looks more beautiful!


but it takes more practice to perfect the application.thank god im a fast learner!


its up to you wich do u prefer! pencil is easy to use!
LOL, I've had that same experience a couple of times, but I've found an eyeliner that I like that doesn't do that, so I'm in love with my liquid eyeliner.
pencil is so much easier to use for me. it doesnt get everywhere, and your less likely to mess up. but, for some, liquid is better.
I like pencil because it's more natural looking and it's easier to apply so it usually looks better.
Pencil eyeliner all the way, because it's much easier to put on your eyes and liquid is very difficult.
Pencil. I suck at liquid and its way harder to draw one line.... itsharder to smudge and really thin... i just use it when i want a really dark color or i dont have a pencil. ;)
PENCIL !!! i hate liquid eye liner, the same thing happened to me, except my eye wasn't entirely black, Thank God ! pencil is so much better and liquid gets smudged real easily
pencil because I always wear eyeliner on my water line and it is not good to wear liquid on the water line.
Wow but you can only use Liquid eyeliner for your top leyelid not under on the bottom. I use both.
I love pencil eyeliner because it's more precise and doesn't make a huge mess.
I like liquid eye liner but it always goes in my eyes after an hour too. So i stick with the pencil.
Liquid by far.





I love that sharp defined line, and it lasts so much longer than pencil.
Liquid because you have more control when you know how to use it and it's a lot darker.
Both...pencil on my bottom and liquid on top so that i can wing it out.
Pencil eye liner. I've never used liquid one.
both..


when i wanna go more dramatic


liquid


but daily


pencil
Pencil





It's SO much easier to apply
liquid
I wouldn't know, I don't use it.
liquid, or powder with one of those cool angled brush! =)


pencil feels like im stabbing my eye. lol
I preffer pencil!