Liquid eyeliner or pencil eye liner?which is better and why?

liquid eyeliner -


pros : stays there for a long time and doesnt smudge, leak or smear,


you get a defined precise line


easier to apply





cons : once you screw up it takes alot to fix it.


more expensive


you dont get the smudy smokey look,


thin lined, like, it looks like you took a marker and put it on your eyes .





i think its more difficult to use if you're just getting used to eyeliner.





pencil eyeliner -


pros : comes in about 48543 colors and textures.


easy to smudge to make different effects,


comes in waterproof so if you do smudge it doesnt leak all over your face.


easier to use, or correct.


cheaper !





cons : most pencils smudge or leak alot quicker or easier.


sharpening is constantly annoying.


the wood can sometime poke at your eye.


if you dont get a good eyeliner, it can pull at your skin if its too hard.


takes a while to find the perfect pencil for you.





i prefer pencil over liquid any day. but whatever floats your boat.





bonne bell, almay, cover girl, mac, new york color make pretty good eyeliners !Liquid eyeliner or pencil eye liner?which is better and why?
liquid eyeliner on the top of the lash line as it is more bolder effective n less likely 2 smudge and pencil in the inner n outter 4 smoky effect so ya can smudge it!! rimmel liquid eyeliner is gr8 i swear by it n borjouis eyepencil black at 1 end white on other!!Liquid eyeliner or pencil eye liner?which is better and why?
My preference is pencil eyeliner that's slightly soft. The dry stuff doesn't work well. Try Revlon or Rimmel. Also, if your really pale, go with a charcoal color, rather than black. But if your tan, go for blackest black!
i use bare minerals liner shadows, wet, or dry.
liquid , it makes ur eyes more defined %26amp; it doesn't smudge %26amp; it stays on longer
Just 1 guy's opinion, but I really can't stand eyeliner. Au naturale for me!
I don't like liquid very much because if your hand slips one little bit you get it everywhere. With pencil, you have to press a little harder so it is harder to make mistakes. Also, you can smudge pencil eyeliner and make the smoky eyes look. You can't do that with liquid.
Liquid has more endurance, however without a steady hand and some practice, it's a bit tricky at first! Keep some q tips nearby so that you can erase any mistakes.





Pencil is good because you can easily smudge it to get that smoky look to your eyes. Both have good qualities!
Pencil - way easier to use, lots of colours and it's smudgeable (gives a smoky look).