What is a good liquid eye liner?

I'm looking for a black liquid eyeliner which is easy to use, not too thick liquid, and now too hard to wash off.





I bought MAC the other week and it's ok... it's kind of hard to apply, thick liquid, and REALLY hard to remove....





I apply it to the upper eye lid. think across my lid and then it extend a little by my edge of my eyes...





HELP! :)





it looks like this:





http://i.ehow.com/images/GlobalPhoto/Art鈥?/a>What is a good liquid eye liner?
If I were you, I wouldn't bother using any eyeliner.


I don't find it at all attractive. Just use a little eyeshadow, that looks much nicer.