What eye liner is better? Pencil, liquid, or gel?

Liquid liners are better when it comes to defining the eyes, but I do not like to wear them because they are too messy. The experts believe that before using liquid liners, you should use a pencil liner and then use the liquid liner on top so that you can create the right shape. MAC gel liner is known for being the best liner however because it stays on and does a great job in defining the eyes.What eye liner is better? Pencil, liquid, or gel?
i use those crayon-alike. its similiar to lipstick. like you turn the thing, and the lipstick comes up. roughly you get what i mean? so i dont have to sharpen it. it works quite well for me. i would wish to try liquid eye liner anyway.What eye liner is better? Pencil, liquid, or gel?
pencil because it is easier to put on
I use liquid too, on the top eye lid, above the lashes. It makes the lashes look thicker and gives you that vintage movie star look. Use pencil for the rest
Pencil or the twist-up kind is good for speedy everyday application. It's also easier to smudge or wipe off if you mess up. Gels and liquids are fantastic for dressy occasions -- they really give that little something ';extra.';
I use liquid.It's a little hard to learn how to use it at first but the results are excellent.
liquid on the top of the lashes, pencil on the bottom .... perfect x
well pencil is what i use it is the easiest and stays on just fine.
cream based eyeliners
liquid is good if you're going for a very dramatic and precise look (don't smudge it!)...pencil is good to be smudged so you look all smokey...never tried gel...
My favourites are the MAC gel liner pots - blacktrack sees a lot of use from me. I like to apply it with a very sharply cut synthetic angle liner brush, and i apply below my upper lashes and it stays all day. Pencils always bleed and make yukky black sleepy, and liquids can crack. They all have their place though - and I have had good results with wet eyeshadow. Another product I liked was the Max Factor felt tip black liner pen - it doesnt last long though.


If you are lining the inside of your eye I cannot recommend the MAC gels highly enough. Outside your eye others work well.


Its all down to preference of application really!